Has anyone compared the Generac GP generators vs the XG genertors?
I'm comparing the GP 6500 with 389 cc engine (splash lubrication) to the XG 6500 with a 410 cc industrial engine (oil pump pump lubrication).
I would be using it for home emergency use, so I doubt I really need the industrial engine with oil pump. Over 10 years it will probably only get 100 hours on the engine mostly at a consistent 50% load with occasional short term peaks closer to max (toaster, sump pump coffee pot, etc). So I'm leaning towards the cheaper GP. But want to consider the following:
Are they both easy to pull start? The biggest engine I pull start is my snowblower with a 250cc OHV Briggs. But when starting only the engine is turned, i.e. it's not engaged to the snowblower yet. The hardest thing I have to start is my power washer with a 160cc OHV Kohler. I think because it's directly connected to the pump which makes it harder to start.
Is the XG industrial engine quieter than the GP engine?
I always tell people to make sure the electrical equipment that will be provided electric power by the generator is electrically shut off before you start the generator. This is much like starting a car in neutral. Trying to start the generator under load is like trying to start a car while it is in gear - it takes a lot more to start it. Having said that, I do not believe the additional 21 cc displacement (5 % difference in displacement) would be harder to start.
The industrial engine will perform more reliably especially under a long run. If you know the electrical outage will run about 1 - 2 hours, the more reliable long term runner is not substantial. However, if the outage runs for 24 or more hours, the splash lubricated non-industrial engine may be stressed and failed. Should this happen, it may be impossible to get it repaired while the electric feed is still out. Can you predict the duration of the outage?
If you need reliable emergency electrical energy, you are probably best served by a more reliable generator. If you can live with an unreliable emergency electrical energy supply, you may ask yourself why you need any emergency energy supply. I have seen generators fail after 12 - 24 hours continual use, even when run at 50% nameplate capacity demand.
Industrial engines are better built, run cooler, and run quieter as a general rule. Further they will run a lot longer durations and for more years. This is one reason they cost more.
Keep in mind is that inductive loads (e.g. motors) draw a lot more to start than they draw once running. A motor that draws 4 amps at 240 v AC can easily draw 8 - 10 amps to start. This is quite a load for a generator.
I strongly suggest you use synthetic engine oil in a generator. These oils take the extreme operating conditions with less breakdown - and you do not want to change oil during an outage. These oils also do not have the major viscosity increase in cold weather which means an engine with synthetic oil of the proper multigrade for the engine will be a lot easier to start in cold weather than will the same engine with non-synthetic oil in it.
Finally since there will be long periods when the engine is not used (because the utility provided electricity is working), you should, after each use, service the engine properly and prepare it for long term lay-up as the engine manual recommends. You can have a generator idle for many months and if you do not lay it up properly corrosion inside the cylinder walls will set in and this can be a major problem that will inhibit or prevent start up when you need it most. Do the preventative maintenance steps each time.
The Generac® generator product line, made by Generac Power Systems, Inc., is well known for dependable operation and long lasting reliability. Depending on the application and installation of the generators, choosing just the right system can be a complex decision. It's always a good idea to consult with the advice of a professional, but here are a few of the important things to consider when choosing the right Generac generator for your unique needs.
Factor In Power Capabilities
One of the very first important considerations when choosing just the right Generac generator for your specific needs is whether or not it will generate sufficient electricity to power everything required. From One Phase 120V for many basic household needs to Three Phase 208V and beyond, it's probably a good idea to step up to a generator that provides the next level of power than you actually require.
Assess Portability Requirements
This is more of a basic consideration, but do realize there's a difference between portable generators and permanently installed backup type generators. Nonetheless, depending on needs, portability is definitely something to consider.
Understand Prices Range With Power
With Generac generator prices covering the range from a couple hundred dollars to tens of thousands of dollars, price is a major factor in the selection process. Portable generators are usually the least expensive units, followed by permanently installed automatic standby backup power systems. From there, generators designed for robust commercial and industrial applications fill out the higher end of the pricing scale.
Consider Generator Sound Output
Because generators use internal combustion motors typically running at moderate speeds to create electricity, the sound output levels can sometimes be an issue-especially in residential applications where restrictive noise ordinances are in place (along with the desire to be a good neighbor). Fortunately, many generators are designed to operate very quietly. The noise factor is something that should be taken into account.
Ensure Sufficient Cooling Systems
Generac generators are available in both air cooled and liquid cooled models. For lower power generators like portables and smaller residential units, air cooling is sufficient and economical. However, as power requirements increase, more powerful engines require a more powerful liquid cooling system for efficient operation. One additional note here-installation of air cooled systems is usually less complex than installing liquid cooled generators.
Choose The Appropriate Fuel Type
While there are many factors and advantages that should be part of the decision when choosing a propane (LP) powered generator or a natural gas fueled system, the biggest factor is usually whether or not natural gas is already piped in. Natural gas is supplied by utility companies via their pipeline distribution network, whereas LP is delivered and stored in external tanks.
Select Enclosure Type
Many Generac generators are available with either steel or aluminum external enclosures. There is a difference depending on application. While steel is generally more cost-effective in most installations, aluminum is often chosen for its lasting durability and high resistance to corroding.
Arranging Installation
It's important to have a professional install and maintain non-portable generators. Because complex transfer switch electrical systems are part of the installation, expert knowledge is important for safety and correct operation.
While choosing the best Generac generator for your unique application can be a complex process, it's always good to know that a properly sized, installed, and maintained generator will offer many reliable years of service.
If you need a motor home rental, you have come to right place! Check out our extensive list of travel trailer rentals, used recreational vehicles rentals, tent trailer rentals, and so much more… Sahara RV Center is Nevada’s #1 recreational vehicle dealer. We service Las Vegas, Henderson, Clark County but we can service you anywhere throughout the country as well! If you are looking for a private motor home rental, we will help you find the right RV for you. Sahara RV Center is a family owned business which has operated for over 25 years at the same Las Vegas, Nevada location. We are a full line RV dealership offering: Rentals, sales, consignment, service / repairs, and a 10,000 sq ft parts store. Our sales department offers the largest pre-owned inventory in Las Vegas! Our Rental department offers various sized RV’s and the only rentals of Tent trailers, Travel Trailers & Toy Haulers in the region. Sahara RV Center’s staff can do almost any service or repair that you require.
We offer Starcraft travel trailers, tent trailers and slide on campers, Cherokee 5th wheels and travel trailers and Sunseeker class C motor homes. Our pre-owned inventory generally includes a large selection of clean, affordable, older and newer model motor homes, 5th wheels and travel trailers. Our late model rentals include Georgetown class a motor homes, Sunseeker class C motor homes, Cherokee and extreme lite travel trailers and Starcraft tent trailers.
Rental rates are for a minimum of 3 days, unless over holidays or special events. Rates also vary depending of the size of the motor home, travel trailer or tent trailer and whether it’s rented during peak season or off season.
Our Super Center Parts store has over 10,000 sq ft of almost any merchandise you may need for your recreational vehicle. We have major appliances such as refrigerators, water heaters, ACs and swamp coolers. We carry a variety of hitches, generators, solar panels, awnings, bathroom fixtures and holding tanks, just to mention a few products. And if we don’t have it, we can special order it and ship it anywhere in the country.
Our Service Department has over 50 years experience and can handle service and warranties on brand name appliances such as: Coleman, Dometic, A&E, Magic Chef, Suburban, Hydroflame, Norcold, Wedgewood, Shurflo, Atwood.
We also specialize in expert 110 & 12 electrical trouble shooting, fresh water & waste water plumbing, air conditioners, swamp coolers, furnaces, ranges, refrigerators, water pumps, water heaters, propane system testing and repair, body repair (fiberglass or metal), electric brake controllers, solar panels, charge regulators, invertors and awnings for all RVs. We service brakes on all recreational vehicle models also!
We can also install T.V.s, microwaves, refrigerators, air conditioners, and anything else you could want or need in your recreational vehicle.
Contact Sahara RV Center Today and let us make your dreams come true… Fill out one of our online Forms and reserve your recreational vehicle to begin a journey that will last you a lifetime!
About the Author:
Sahara RV Center a Full line RV Dealership offering Sales, Consignment, Service, Rentals and a 10,000 sq. ft. Parts Store operating in and around Las Vegas. For more information, visit sahararv.com
